Ai & Innovation, part 2

 Pascal Dennis, co-author of Harnessing Digital Disruption

What’s the greatest danger posed by AI? The brutal fallacy that human creativity & achievement are nothing. ‘Look,’ AI tells us, ‘I can create a poem, essay, song, image in thirty seconds!’  Hence the proliferation of AI slop.

AI engines are akin to a smart intern or research assistant. In the hands of a skilled practitioner, AI saves time & effort, freeing us up to get at the crux of the problem or job at hand. Beware using AI as a crutch or a short cut. Learn the fundamentals of your chosen business, discipline or art. Put in the needed reps, cloister yourself with you craft, remote from AI support. Why, you ask? Because practice makes you smarter. And not doing so, asking AI to do the reps for you will surely make you dumber.

That said, AI can be very helpful to the innovator. Let me use the music to illustrate the point. As some of you may know, I am a dedicated composer & musician. (Management & Music are my ‘twin pillars’, and my family is my foundation).

To compose, say, a jazz ballad, you have to understand music theory, and in particular, jazz harmony. And you have to know your chosen instrument(s). Suppose you begin with a basic melody and a I – VII – III – II – V – I structure. How do we innovate?

Well, we can use chord extensions; that is, we can add the 2, 4, 6 or 7 to a given chord to give it the emotion we’re seeking (tension, anticipation, brightness, melancholy…). Then we can make the extension sharp or flat, or we can add multiple extensions, say, a 6 & a 9 on the tonic chord and 6 & flat 7 on the subdominant. Our progression is taking on a personality, an edge, a feeling. Now we can consider modulating to a different key, which is akin to entering a new room in a beautiful house. Or we can modulate to series of keys, which is akin to a series of rooms.

You get the picture. Absent an intuitive understanding of these things, gained by long & patient study, can anybody really innovate - with or without AI? To be sure, you can ask an AI music site to create a song for your spouse about a giraffe & hippo in the style of Willie Nelson, with a solo in the style of Chet Atkins – but is that innovation?

No, it’s AI slop.  (And even worse, it is stealing from Willie & Chet, no?)

And so, each of us must learn their craft under the guidance of a mentor, a sensei – one who has ‘gone before’. AI can help us in the same way as a smart intern or research assistant can help. By saving us time, by reducing hassle, by doing repetitive stuff that frees us up to do the hard working of thinking, experimenting and creating.

Do I use AI to help me write songs?  Short answer – No. I’ve played with AI in the manner I described above.  ‘Here is a chord sequence in the key of F minor. What kind of chord extensions or key modulations are possible?’  Like any smart intern, AI tries to be helpful. ‘Hey boss, did you consider adding a flat 9 to the dominant chord? 

But I already thought about that. It takes our producer & my composition coach, maestro David Logan, to suggest something truly cool like: ‘Try adding a flat 9 and a sharp 9 to the dominant…”

Now we’re talking…

Best wishes,

Pascal Dennis         E: pascal.dennis@leansystems.org

In case you missed earlier blogs... please feel free to have another look….

AI Without Acumen = Garbage at the Speed of Light
Smart Growth (continued) - the Hacker
Smart Growth - the Huslter
The Difference Between Protecting Your Core Business & Igniting New Growth