How Good is Your Management System?

 

What’s the purpose of a ‘management system’? What are its key elements? What are common failure modes?  How do you know if you have a good one?

My job the past few decades has been to help our partners meet their business goals by developing strong people & management systems. My personal mission is to teach leaders Ambidexterity – the ability to both

a) Protect the core with OpEx/Lean, and

2) Ignite new Growth using the methods of Silicon Valley & Singapore.

Your management system enables both and is analogous to the wire harnesses that enable high performance airplanes & automobiles. I’ve written at length about the questions above. In this piece I’d like to describe the tell-tale attribute of a great management system.

Key Attributes of World Class Management Systems

World class management systems make problems visible.

By ‘problem’ I mean the difference between

·       What Should Be Happening, and

·       What is Actually Happening

Each of these must at least define purpose, process & key metrics. By ‘visible’ I mean obvious to all team members.  ‘Everybody knows’, to paraphrase Leonard Cohen.

In practice this means that problems are painfully clear at team boards at every level - from the Senior Leader Obeya to front line team boards & huddle sessions. When I’m asked by a Board or Senior Team to ‘assess our management system’, a key step is to walk the value stream backwards, starting with the customer, and moving upstream one step at a time. A parallel step entails walking the customer journey backstream, starting with the top of the proverbial funnel.

In my value stream walks, I ask questions like:

·       Are problems visible (even to an outsider like me)?

·       What do people talk about in their huddles? Are problems understood & addressed in a clear & decisive way?

·       What’s the organization’s attitude to problems? Are problems hidden, a sign of failure? Or are they, to quote W. Edwards Deming, ‘the process speaking to us’?

·       Do teams have a standard approach to problem solving?

·       How good is the data? Is it complete, end to end, and of high quality?

·       Does the team develop ‘Your Own Data’ (YODA) as required? Or do they passively wait for corporate data?

Here are your key checkpoints:

·       The visibility of problems, and

·       Quality of problem solving (the focus of upcoming articles)

I vividly remember an engagement with a large multinational consumer goods company.  They were good, capable people and their company had enjoyed strong growth for several years. They’d invested in teaching their team members root cause problem solving. I spent a few weeks walking the most important value streams from the customer all the way upstream. I attended team huddles and walked the shop floor.

I presented my findings to the COO & senior management team:

·       Everything looks good on the surface – purpose strategies seem cogent, data seems to be flow, workplace fundamentals look okay on the surface (e.g., 5S, standardized work, visual management), and morale is fairly good.

·       But there's flashing RED light – team boards at all levels are always Green; the critical third wall of the Obeya (Blockers) is usually empty.

‘But we’ve given everybody problem solving training,’ the team responded. ‘

There's flashing RED light,’ I repeated, and added the my old sensei' motto, ‘No problem, is a big problem.’

My report fell on deaf ears.

Six months later there were major outbreaks of food poisoning related to their products. Several customers became ill, and the company’s brand suffered serious damage. A number of senior leaders resigned.

The visibility of problems and quality of problem solving are your early warning system, and a key to de-risking your enterprise.  You want to assess your management system?  Start there.

Best wishes,

Pascal Dennis         E: pascal.dennis@leansystems.org